"Leadership
that Listens"
Leadership That Listens · Jackie Hendy for West Orange Town Council · 2026
Jackie Hendy is a committed West Orange resident who believes local government should work for the people, not the other way around.
She has seen decisions move forward without enough public input, and contracts approved without a clear understanding of their long-term impact. She's running because West Orange deserves better: clearer answers, smarter planning, and a local government that holds itself to the same standards it sets for everyone else.
"Good decisions don't fear questions. Bad ones hide from them."
Jackie listens before she acts. She'll push for structural reforms that make local government more open, more responsive, and more accountable on every vote, every contract, and every dollar spent. Showing up matters. It also has to be backed by good decision-making.
West Orange is at a critical point. The township carries more than $171 million in long-term debt, and a meaningful share of the budget now goes toward paying for past decisions. That limits flexibility and adds pressure on taxpayers. At the same time, costs keep rising for many families, it's getting harder to stay here.
West Orange needs a clearer long-term plan: one that strengthens commercial ratables, invests in our downtown corridors, addresses affordable housing responsibly, protects open space and the environment, and makes sure our infrastructure can handle what's being built.
Right now, development is moving forward without a clearly communicated plan for how that growth fits together, or what it means for schools, roads, and services.
This comes down to structure. Major decisions should be fully understood before they're approved. That means time to review, clear information, and consistent standards for how decisions are made. That's what Jackie is focused on: better planning before commitments are made, clearer information before votes are taken, and stronger safeguards so decisions reflect the long-term interests of West Orange residents.
One goal: a West Orange government that actually works for its residents. Four concrete areas of focus. Reforms that will change how the West Orange government operates.
No contract comes before council without full public documentation at least 72 hours in advance. Every agreement gets a plain English summary written for residents, not lawyers and must disclose any political donations from the company receiving the contract.
Every major agreement must show the full cost over the life of the deal, who benefits financially, and what happens if things go wrong. Clear benchmarks, regular check-ins, and real exit clauses mean West Orange always has leverage and a way out.
The council and the public should never be the last to know what the administration is doing. Monthly or quarterly public reports, plus a formal written Q&A process before every vote, will help ensure decisions get made in the open.
West Orange already has rules on the books to protect trees, steep slopes, and neighborhoods from flooding and runoff they just aren't always enforced. Jackie will make sure developers can't quietly carve out exceptions to the rules that keep our neighborhoods safe.
These are real issues. Each one has played out in West Orange in contracts signed, deals gone wrong, and decisions made before residents had a chance to weigh in.
Contracts can be amended after public posting meaning the terms residents reviewed on Friday may not match the document voted on Monday. By the time most people find out, it's already done.
West Orange has begun outlining steps to manage its debt, but there is still no clearly defined, comprehensive long-term financial framework guiding major decisions. Too often, agreements move forward without a complete picture of total cost over time including borrowing, foregone revenue, and what happens if assumptions don't hold.
While political contributions by vendors are disclosed under state law, that information is not consistently presented in a clear, contract-by-contract format at the time decisions are made. West Orange previously maintained a local disclosure provision, but that was repealed following changes to state law. Jackie's focus is simple: if information exists, it should be easy to see before a vote, not after.
West Orange paid $12.5 million to settle litigation and reacquire the Prism property, then assumed all remaining environmental liabilities with no public accounting of what they would cost taxpayers. The Matrix agreement moved forward before a studio partner was even identified. Neither deal included publicly disclosed performance standards or exit terms that residents could evaluate before the vote.
Though West Orange provides agendas and materials in advance, the current process allows for changes, additions, and amendments shortly before a vote including items introduced close to the meeting itself. The current structure also places significant administrative authority with the Mayor's office, but does not clearly require standardized, ongoing public reporting to the council on major contracts, spending, or project performance. That makes it harder to maintain consistent oversight and track outcomes over time.
In 2021, 45 families were evacuated after a rockslide on Northfield Avenue. The town updated its steep slope ordinance in response. Less than a mile away, a new developer is now seeking nine variances three from that same ordinance on the same type of slope.
On Tuesday night, the West Orange Township Council unanimously settled the Daughters of Israel builder’s remedy lawsuit. Given the circumstances, this was probably the best outcome we could reasonably hope for — but that doesn’t make it any less frustrating.
Read More →Throughout this campaign, we’ve been asked to share our vision for West Orange. I’ve spent a lot of time talking about the smaller things we can do — but I think it’s worth talking about the bigger dreams, too.
Read More →Residents pay millions each year under the name “sewer fee.” That money goes into the general fund. Then we borrow millions more for sewer repairs. Residents are paying twice — and deserve to know why.
Read More →That is what I aim for every time I write about someone in government, whether it is a sitting council member, a candidate, the administration, or a vote itself. And as I comb through the complicated, often frustrating history of how we got here, and more importantly, how we find our way out, I find myself repeating that mantra.
Read More →Sewer bills are rolling in and neighbors are reeling. Here’s what the CFO actually said at Tuesday’s meeting — and why it may turn out to be the beginning of something better.
Read More →West Orange is navigating affordable housing, climate resilience, and where density belongs — guided by a plan rooted in 2004. Here’s what that’s cost us, and what fixing it actually requires.
Read More →We were promised a brand new library at no cost to taxpayers. Here’s what that promise has actually cost West Orange — and what it means for every deal still ahead of us.
Read More →West Orange designated this land for transit-oriented development in 2008. Construction still hasn’t started. Here’s what happened, what we’re still owed, and why this window won’t stay open much longer.
Read More →The mayor is proposing a 7.26% municipal tax increase and the budget arrived late, again, with no presentation and no explanation.
Read More →PILOT stands for Payment In Lieu of Taxes. Instead of paying regular property taxes like you and I do, certain developers negotiate a separate annual fee with the township.
Read More →West Orange, we need to talk about Essex Green. For years, we’ve kicked the can on our affordable housing obligation.
Read More →Tuesday’s Council meeting didn’t end until the early hours of Wednesday morning. The Council went into executive session for three hours, so public comment didn’t even start until around 10 PM.
Read More →The mayor is proposing a 7.26% municipal tax increase and the budget arrived late, again, with no presentation and no explanation.
And it lands at a difficult moment. Many residents are still processing last year's revaluation — a correction that brought assessments to market rate, but one that was disorienting and deeply unsettling for a lot of households. Asking residents to absorb a significant new increase before that dust has settled is a lot to ask.
Before asking residents to pay more, we should be able to answer a few basic questions: Where is spending increasing and why, what's actually been evaluated for savings, and where is the long-term plan so we're not having this same conversation every year?
Here's what says everything: Council members are debating it. Candidates are posting about it. And yet if you go to the West Orange township website right now and look for the budget, there's nothing there for 2026. The document that determines what you pay to live here is not available for you to read where it should be, and yet public officials are discussing it. That's not a glitch. That's the problem.
Last year's budget process was called a "debacle" by a sitting councilman. The Council fought a projected 6% increase down to under 1%. We're entering that process again: line by line, department by department, demanding justification for every dollar. And they need to hear from you.
PILOT stands for Payment In Lieu of Taxes. Instead of paying regular property taxes like you and I do, certain developers negotiate a separate annual fee with the township. Two major West Orange developments operate this way: Stonehill and Edison Lofts. Both were presented to residents as revenue generators. New development, new income for the township. Good for everyone. But was it?
Here's what wasn't disclosed. When these deals were approved, the township borrowed money to pay for the infrastructure that made them possible. They issued redevelopment area bonds — and those bonds get paid back from the PILOT revenue itself. So when Stonehill or Edison Lofts makes its annual payment, a legally pledged portion goes straight to bond repayment before it ever reaches our general fund. It cannot pay for police, fire, or snow removal.
Think of it this way: the township was promised a $1,000 raise. What residents weren't told is that $400 is already garnished. We were shown the gross number, not the net.
There's a second problem. Regular property taxes adjust automatically when township costs rise. PILOT payments don't — they're fixed by the original agreement. The CFO confirmed that both developments are showing declining revenue relative to projections.
These deals were sold as a financial win for West Orange. The bond obligations weren't disclosed. The revenue is underperforming. Keep this in mind the next time you hear about a proposed PILOT.
West Orange, we need to talk about Essex Green.
For years, we've kicked the can on our affordable housing obligation. No certified plan, no township planner, and no proactive vision. Just reactive scrambling as developer after developer shows up with applications we're legally vulnerable to reject. That vulnerability is the cost of inaction.
I just finished a book called Strong Towns, built around one core insight: sustainable communities build where infrastructure already exists. Now, walk with me across the AMC parking lot at Essex Green. See that courtyard? Imagine it differently: trees, benches, conversation seating, people actually living here rather than just passing through.
Here's what's driving my urgency: we have a legal affordable housing obligation we cannot escape. Six builder's remedy lawsuits are waiting, each proposing large-scale rentals on our open space, barely making a dent in what we actually owe while locking us into decades of new infrastructure obligations.
Essex Green already has everything: Route 280 access, utilities in the ground, parking, public transit. It was designated an Area in Need of Redevelopment in 2018 and we just... didn't. A neighborhood living above and beside the retail is exactly the captive, walkable audience that keeps a commercial center alive — and we address a significant chunk of our housing obligation, protect our open space, and a properly structured PILOT could direct revenue toward our schools.
This is a concept, not a finished plan. But every plan starts somewhere, and this conversation is years overdue.
Tuesday's Council meeting didn't end until the early hours of Wednesday morning. The Council went into executive session for three hours, so public comment didn't even start until around 10 PM. That's not a meeting. That's an endurance test designed — whether intentionally or not — to exhaust the public out of the room.
And what were they voting on? West Orange's new police chief will earn nearly $300,000 in total compensation. For context: New York City's police chief, overseeing 33,000 officers, makes $290,000. Newark's chief makes $269,000. Jersey City's makes $234,000. We have 98 officers.
Our mayor makes unilateral decisions on hiring and compensation, shuts the Council out completely, then drops contracts in their laps after the fact. By the time it gets to a vote, the deal is already done. Approve it or face legal chaos. That's not a choice. That's a hostage situation.
This is the same mayor who handed her Business Administrator a 55% raise — $74,000 more per year — without Council input. The pattern is clear and it is costly.
West Orange is not a wealthy town. Our residents feel our financial challenges every day. Our elected officials have a fiduciary duty to govern like they know that. Had I been on that dais, I would have voted no. West Orange deserves better. It's time to say so out loud, and to do something about it.
Whether you want to volunteer, host a house party, or put up a yard sign every neighbor who joins makes this campaign stronger.
Every contribution big or small helps us reach more West Orange neighbors.
Donate TodayYou Are Cordially Invited
Reception & Celebration
Date & Time
Sunday, June 7
3PM – 5PM
Location
Castle Rock
440 Main Street, West Orange, NJ
Support the Campaign
Select your tier on the next page
Tickets available online. Walk-ins welcome — contributions of any amount accepted at the door.
Get TicketsPaid for by Jackie Hendy for West Orange Town Council
June 2026
Tap a highlighted date to view event details
Affordability is the issue I hear about most, and as a Realtor I saw firsthand how bad it got. When the town didn't pass its budget until November, well beyond the typical timeline, the new tax rate still hadn't been released. That meant the old rate was being applied to newly reassessed property values, and platforms like Zillow and Trulia were showing numbers that didn't reflect reality. Clients were calling me in a panic. Homeowners and potential future residents were making major financial decisions based on inaccurate information, and that's a direct consequence of a broken budget process.
The revaluation itself also hit many residents hard with significant increases that came quickly and without much time to prepare. When costs rise without clear communication or predictability, people lose confidence in the system. My focus is on bringing more discipline and clarity to that process:
We have legal obligations under state law and the consequences of ignoring them are real. Towns that don't get ahead of their Fair Share requirements end up facing builder's remedy lawsuits, which hand control of where and what gets built directly to developers. The question isn't whether we meet our obligations, it's whether we do it thoughtfully or get forced into it.
Right now, West Orange is in a reactive posture, responding to builder-driven proposals because there hasn't been a clear, proactive plan in place. That needs to change. My focus would be:
West Orange sits on one of the most environmentally significant landscapes in Essex County. The Watchung Ridge runs through our town, and the open space, tree canopy, and natural drainage it supports aren't just scenic, they're functional infrastructure. When we allow development on steep slopes without proper review, or remove mature trees without accountability, we create flooding problems downstream, destabilize hillsides, and permanently alter the character of our neighborhoods.
Growth and preservation aren't mutually exclusive, but they require clear standards and the discipline to enforce them. That means:
West Orange's downtown is not one place. It is four distinct corridors, each with its own character and needs: The Valley, St. Mark's, Tory Corner, and Eagle Rock. The Downtown West Orange Alliance already does meaningful work across all of them, and any serious plan should build on that partnership.
The core issue is that too much development still happens one project at a time, without a clear vision for what each corridor should become. Each corridor requires a different approach. The Valley and St. Mark's show the most visible vacancy and turnover, and need focused economic activity and stability. Tory Corner already has the physical foundation for a walkable downtown, but the commercial mix has not kept pace with that potential. Eagle Rock presents a different challenge, with a more auto-oriented layout that calls for a different set of tools.
Across all of them, the fundamentals need to be addressed:
Another issue we need to address is overconcentration of the same types of businesses within a single corridor. When similar uses cluster too heavily, it limits variety and reduces the overall draw of the area. Some New Jersey towns have taken steps through zoning and redevelopment planning to manage that balance and encourage a more diverse mix of businesses. That kind of approach is worth examining in West Orange, particularly in areas where clustering has already taken hold.
A stronger downtown also depends on making it easier to open and sustain a business. Right now, that process is slower and more complicated than it should be, and that burden falls most heavily on small, independent operators who give these corridors their character.
Contracts can be amended after public posting meaning the terms residents reviewed on Friday may not match the document voted on Monday. By the time most people find out, it's already done.
Jackie's Fix: No contract comes before council without final documentation locked 72 hours in advance. No late additions. No last-minute amendments.
When companies doing business with West Orange make political donations to the officials approving their contracts, that information is technically available. But it's not attached to the contract, and most residents will never see it.
Jackie's Fix: Every professional service contract must include mandatory disclosure of political contributions attached to the contract, visible to every resident before the vote.
West Orange has no structured long-term budget plan. Major agreements move forward without a complete picture of total cost over the life of the deal including bonds, tax revenue foregone, and what happens if something goes wrong.
Jackie's Fix: Every major agreement must show the full cost over the life of the deal, who benefits financially, and what happens if things go wrong.
West Orange paid $12.5 million to settle litigation and reacquire the Prism property, then assumed all remaining environmental liabilities with no public accounting of what they would cost taxpayers. The Matrix agreement moved forward before a studio partner was even identified. Neither deal included publicly disclosed performance standards or exit terms that residents could evaluate before the vote.
Read more: Edison Village Redevelopment · Movie Studio Proposal Vote
Jackie's Fix: Clear benchmarks, regular check-ins, and real exit clauses mean West Orange always has leverage and a way out.
The Mayor's office is not required to deliver regular public reports to the full council on contracts, spending, or major projects. Council members have had to ask questions on the fly during public meetings without advance notice of what's on the agenda.
Read more: Mayor & Council Standoff Over Town Attorney
Jackie's Fix: Introduce a formal requirement for monthly or quarterly public reports from the administration to the full council delivered in advance, on the record.
In 2021, 45 families were evacuated after a rockslide on Northfield Avenue. The town updated its steep slope ordinance in response. Less than a mile away, a new developer is now seeking nine variances three from that same ordinance on the same type of slope.
Jackie's Fix: Push to strengthen West Orange's steep slope and tree ordinances so the standards are clear, specific, and hard to waive, while advocating for consistent enforcement.
No contract comes before council without full public documentation at least 72 hours in advance. Every agreement gets a plain English summary written for residents, not lawyers and must disclose any political donations from the company receiving the contract.
Every major agreement must show the full cost over the life of the deal, who benefits financially, and what happens if things go wrong. Clear benchmarks, regular check-ins, and real exit clauses mean West Orange always has leverage and a way out.
The council and the public should never be the last to know what the administration is doing. Monthly or quarterly public reports, plus a formal written Q&A process before every vote, mean decisions get made in the open not in back channels.
West Orange already has rules on the books to protect trees, steep slopes, and neighborhoods from flooding and runoff they just aren't always enforced. Jackie will make sure developers can't quietly carve out exceptions to the rules that keep our neighborhoods safe.
Jacqueline “Jackie” Hendy has called West Orange home for 18 years. She has lived in the Valley, Gregory, and Hazel communities, and as a local real estate business owner, she has helped families buy and sell homes across nearly every neighborhood in town, giving her a ground-level understanding of the rich diversity of our town, what makes each neighborhood unique, and the different needs of every part of town.
Across every chapter of her career from the stage to the boardroom to the closing table Jackie has worked at the intersection of collaboration, process, and execution: bringing people together around a shared goal, building the structure to get there, and seeing it through to something real.
That career spans Broadway and television, contract and legal document work for major international law firms, and years of parent advocacy, including navigating IEPs and special services. During the pandemic, she organized a virtual drama program for local students, coordinating with other parents in the creative arts to give kids connection and community when both were in short supply. She also volunteers regularly with local organizations that support neighbors facing food insecurity.
Jackie is running because West Orange deserves higher standards for process, oversight, and leadership. She brings the same discipline and accountability to public service that she has demanded of herself in every room she's worked in.
Proposed Legislation
A plain-language guide to what this ordinance does, why it matters, and what problem it solves for West Orange residents.
⚖️ This ordinance does not take power away from the Mayor. It ensures that before public money is committed, the Council — and by extension, the public — has a real opportunity to weigh in.
West Orange has a process problem — and residents are paying for it.
Under our current system, the Mayor negotiates deals, sets salaries, and commits the Township to contracts — and the Council only finds out when it's time to vote. By then, the deal is already done. Approve it, or face costly legal chaos. That is not oversight. That is a hostage situation.
This pattern has a real cost to residents who already face some of the highest property taxes in Essex County. This has already happened in West Orange — here are the examples on the public record:
Police Chief compensation: Total package approaching $300,000 — more than the police chiefs of New York City, Newark, and Jersey City. The Council saw the terms after they were agreed upon, and voted under implicit threat of legal liability.
Business Administrator raise: A $74,000-per-year increase — a 55% raise — negotiated and committed to without any Council input or vote.
Litigation-as-leverage: The Mayor sued the Township to force an appointment the Council rejected. The settlement terms included compensation commitments that were then presented to the Council for ratification — under the pressure of ongoing litigation.
Six concrete guardrails on executive power.
§3 · Contract Review Requirement
Before any contract worth more than $25,000 is finalized, the complete agreement and a certified cost analysis must be filed publicly. The Council has 21 days to review it before any funding vote.
Why it matters: Right now, contracts can be signed and the Council is handed the bill. This flips that.
§4 · Executive Compensation Transparency
Any salary change for a Township employee earning $100,000 or more requires a full cost analysis posted publicly 14 days before a Council vote. All senior salaries will be posted on the Township website annually.
Why it matters: A 55% raise for the Business Administrator happened with no Council vote. Under this ordinance, that cannot happen.
§5 · Council's Right to Independent Legal Counsel
Any two Council members can request independent legal counsel — a lawyer who works for the Council, not the Mayor — at Township expense. No vote can be scheduled until that counsel delivers a written opinion.
Why it matters: The tactic of "approve this or we'll get sued" depends on the Council not having its own legal advice. This removes that leverage.
§5A · Settlements Cannot Be Used to Set Salaries
If a lawsuit settlement includes compensation terms for any Township employee, those terms must go through the same transparency and Council approval process as any other pay change.
Why it matters: Compensation obligations have been slipped into settlement agreements and presented under litigation pressure. This closes that loophole.
§5B · Mayor Cannot Sue the Township Without Council Authorization
If the Mayor wants to initiate litigation against the Township, the Council must authorize the funding. Before any vote, the Mayor must provide the legal basis, estimated costs, and a summary of alternatives.
Why it matters: The Mayor previously sued the Township to force an outcome the Council rejected — then used the settlement to impose financial obligations. This provision means the Council controls the checkbook first.
§6 · Reporting and Accountability Rights
Any Council member may request a written report from the Mayor on any contract, compensation decision, or litigation matter — and the Mayor must respond within 14 days. The Council may require the Mayor to appear before them to answer questions from both the Council and the public.
Why it matters: Oversight requires information. This codifies the Council's right to get it — and the public's right to see it.
~$300K
Police chief total compensation — more than NYC, Newark & Jersey City chiefs combined
55%
Business Administrator raise — $74,000/year — with zero Council input
21 days
Minimum public review before any major contract can be funded
~$25K
Threshold above which all contracts require Council review and fiscal analysis
Does this take power away from the Mayor?
No. The Mayor retains full authority to negotiate contracts, set personnel priorities, and run the executive branch. What this ordinance changes is the process for funding those decisions.
Will this slow down routine township business?
It will add a review period for major contracts and senior compensation changes — which is the point. Day-to-day operations are not affected. The Council can also waive the review period by majority vote in a genuine emergency.
What happens if the Mayor ignores the ordinance?
The Council simply will not appropriate the funds. Any Township resident can also petition the Superior Court for enforcement.
How does this become law?
It must be introduced and pass two readings at Council meetings, with a public hearing. West Orange residents also have the right to introduce ordinances directly through a citizen petition signed by 10% of registered voters from the last general election.
This is a plain-language summary of proposed legislation for the Township of West Orange, New Jersey. The full ordinance text governs in all legal matters.
TOWNSHIP OF WEST ORANGE · ESSEX COUNTY, NEW JERSEY
An Ordinance Establishing Executive Compensation Transparency, Pre-Execution Contract Review, Litigation Authorization Requirements, and Council Oversight Requirements for the Township of West Orange
("Executive Accountability and Fiscal Transparency Ordinance")
WHEREAS, the Township of West Orange is governed under Plan B of the Mayor-Council form of government pursuant to the Faulkner Act, N.J.S.A. 40:69A-31 et seq., under which the Council exercises legislative power and the Mayor exercises executive power; and
WHEREAS, the Township Council, as the duly elected legislative body, bears a fiduciary duty to the residents of West Orange to exercise meaningful oversight over the expenditure of public funds and the terms of public employment; and
WHEREAS, a pattern has emerged in which the Mayor has unilaterally negotiated and executed employment agreements and compensation packages — including a Business Administrator compensation increase of approximately $74,000 per year representing a 55% raise — without prior notice to or input from the Township Council; and
WHEREAS, in April 2025, a compensation package for a senior Township executive was presented to the Township Council for ratification only after the terms had already been agreed upon, with total compensation approaching $300,000 annually — a figure exceeding the compensation of the police chiefs of New York City, Newark, and Jersey City; and
WHEREAS, West Orange residents bear one of the highest property tax burdens in Essex County, and the responsible stewardship of public funds requires transparency, deliberation, and checks on executive authority;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Township Council of the Township of West Orange, County of Essex, State of New Jersey, as follows:
1.1 This Ordinance shall be known as the "Executive Accountability and Fiscal Transparency Ordinance of the Township of West Orange."
1.2 The purpose of this Ordinance is to: (a) ensure the Township Council receives timely prior notice before the Township is legally bound to any contract above a specified threshold; (b) require independent fiscal impact analysis for executive compensation changes; (c) guarantee the Council's right to independent legal counsel; (d) establish a public record of all compensation decisions for senior Township positions; and (e) ensure no compensation obligation may be imposed through litigation settlement without satisfying the same transparency and approval requirements.
"Covered Contract" — Any agreement, contract, memorandum of understanding, or binding commitment to which the Township is a party, with a total value exceeding $25,000.
"Covered Position" — Any Township employee or appointee with an annual base salary of $100,000 or more, including the Business Administrator, department directors, the Township attorney, Township engineer, and chief of police.
"Compensation Change" — Any increase in base salary, total compensation, pension contribution, bonus, deferred compensation, allowance, or benefit for a Covered Position.
"Fiscal Impact Statement" — A written analysis certified by the Township CFO identifying: total annualized cost, multi-year projected cost, anticipated funding source, impact on current-year budget, and comparison to compensation for equivalent positions in comparable New Jersey municipalities.
3.1 No fewer than 21 days prior to a Council vote, the complete agreement and a Fiscal Impact Statement signed by the Township CFO shall be filed with the Township Clerk, delivered to each Council member, and posted on the Township's public website within 48 hours.
3.2 The Council may waive the review period by majority vote upon a finding of a bona fide emergency requiring immediate action to protect public health or safety.
3.3 The Township Council shall make no appropriation for any Covered Contract unless the requirements of Section 3.1 have been satisfied.
4.1 No Council vote on any Compensation Change for a Covered Position shall occur unless, no less than 14 days prior: (a) a complete written description has been filed with the Township Clerk and delivered to each Council member; (b) a Fiscal Impact Statement has been certified by the CFO and filed simultaneously; and (c) the proposed change and Fiscal Impact Statement have been posted publicly and included on a publicly noticed Council agenda.
4.2 Money for any Compensation Change made without compliance with this Section shall not be appropriated by the Township Council.
4.3 The Township CFO shall maintain and post publicly an annually updated schedule of total compensation for all Covered Positions.
5.1 When any Covered Contract or proposed Compensation Change is presented to the Council, the Council shall have the right to retain independent legal counsel of its choosing, at Township expense, prior to any vote.
5.2 Upon request by any two Council members, the Township Clerk shall engage independent legal counsel within five (5) business days.
5.3 No vote on a Covered Contract or Compensation Change shall be scheduled until independent counsel has delivered a written opinion, or until 21 days have elapsed from counsel's engagement, whichever occurs first.
5.4 The existence of a threatened or pending legal claim shall not, standing alone, constitute grounds for the Council to approve a Covered Contract or Compensation Change that does not satisfy the requirements of this Ordinance.
5A.1 Any Compensation Change arising from litigation settlement, consent order, or other legal instrument shall be subject to a Township Council vote. No fewer than 14 days prior, compensation terms must be disclosed in writing with a Fiscal Impact Statement, the Council must have opportunity to retain independent counsel, and the Council must approve the compensation terms by recorded majority vote — separate from any vote on other settlement terms.
5A.2 The form of the instrument used to establish a compensation obligation shall not determine whether this Ordinance applies.
5A.4 The existence of litigation pressure or legal uncertainty shall not relieve the Township of the obligation to comply with this Section.
5B.1 The Council has the right to retain independent counsel for any litigation initiated by the Mayor, funded by majority vote approval.
5B.2 The Council shall not appropriate funds in support of any litigation in which the Township is named as defendant or the Mayor seeks relief against the Township, without prior majority vote approval — except in cases of emergency injunctive relief.
5B.3 At least 14 days prior to any Council vote, the Mayor shall provide: the legal basis and factual grounds; an estimate of legal costs; a description of potential financial obligations; and an assessment of alternative dispute resolution options.
5B.5 This Section shall not prohibit the Mayor from seeking emergency injunctive relief in exigent circumstances, provided the Council President and each Council member are notified in writing within 24 hours of filing.
6.1 Any Council member may submit a written request to the Mayor for a report on any compensation decision, contract, or litigation matter. The Mayor shall respond in writing within 14 calendar days.
6.2 The Mayor shall include in each proposed annual budget a complete compensation schedule for all Covered Positions, including any changes from the prior year.
6.3 The Mayor shall provide the Council with a written report of any pending or threatened litigation, updated quarterly.
6.4 The Council may compel the Mayor to appear before it to respond to questions from the Council and the public.
This Ordinance applies to all Covered Contracts, Compensation Changes, litigation filings, and settlements entered into on or after its effective date. It does not impair any vested contractual right existing as of the effective date.
Any Township resident may petition the Superior Court of New Jersey for injunctive or declaratory relief to enforce this Ordinance. The Council may direct its own counsel to seek enforcement.
This Ordinance takes effect upon final passage and publication as required by law, pursuant to N.J.S.A. 40:49-2.
Introduced at a meeting of the Township Council of the Township of West Orange, 2025.
This ordinance is a working draft offered for introduction or citizen petition purposes under the Faulkner Act, N.J.S.A. 40:69A-1 et seq. It should be reviewed by qualified New Jersey municipal law counsel prior to introduction.
West Orange Patch · June 10, 2026
Jackie Hendy Launches West Orange Town Council Bid: 2026 Election
Hendy has laid out a plan to address several local hot-button issues in West Orange.
By Eric Kiefer, Patch Staff
Read Full Article →Greetings West Orange. It’s been a busy few weeks, and before I get into this post, I wanted to share a quick update on what the campaign has been up to. We’ve hosted three more meet and greets, attended our town’s incredible street fair, helped organize the Men Who Cook fundraiser while fulfilling my role as WOAHO secretary, we’ve been canvassing, and I’ve been getting out to meet neighbors at Pride and Juneteenth celebrations here in town. In between all of that, we marked my birthday, my husband’s birthday, and both a solemn and joyful Father’s Day. Life keeps moving, and so does this campaign.
Now, to the post, which comes a little later than usual. The trail of bills, settlements, and history behind this took real time to dig through.
A lot happened at last Wednesday’s Town Council meeting, but one thing in particular is worth sitting with, because it says something important about how this town negotiates with developers, and why that matters for the decisions still ahead of us.
First, I want to be clear about something. This isn’t about the library itself, or the people who work there and the residents who use it every day. They’re making the best of what they were given, and that work matters. This is about the deal that put them there, and what it teaches us about the deals the council will still have to make.
The library at 10 Rooney Circle sits inside a 1971 building the township also rents out to a tenant for income. It was deeded to the township at no cost, as part of the Executive Drive redevelopment deal. In exchange, the developer secured a 30-year PILOT agreement on a 425-unit apartment project. Critics estimated the deal represented $100 million in tax breaks over its lifetime. The administration and some council members disputed that framing, arguing the property had generated depressed revenue for years due to repeated tax appeals, and that the PILOT would actually increase net income to the township. The library, a ~$600,000-a-year TSA lease, and a promised dog park were the public benefit side of that trade.
Then-Mayor Robert Parisi said it himself, in a 2020 statement to the press: the redevelopment would provide the new library, the dog park, senior housing, and community space, while increasing town revenue, “all at no cost to West Orange taxpayers.” That was the promise.
Here’s what it’s actually cost. The project was appropriated at $6,506,217. About half — $3,098,217 — came from a state library construction grant. The rest, roughly $3.4 million, was authorized through a township bond ordinance: real debt, backed by the township’s full taxing power. “At no cost” was never accurate. It was a loan, and we’re still paying it down.
The bills have kept arriving on top of that: elevators, water lines, gas lines, HVAC, roofs — none of it part of the original appropriation. Last July, a sewer line backup sent contaminated water across the lower level, which stayed closed to the public for three months. Each time, the administration has called it “unanticipated.” I facilitate the purchase and sale of real estate for a living, and there is nothing unanticipated about any of it. Every one of those systems has a known life expectancy.
Here’s what we know is still ahead:
Strip out the state grant and the developer’s contribution, and West Orange’s own money in this building comes to roughly $5.2 million so far. And that’s before the elevator work, the water and gas system upgrades, the sewer backup repair, the lighting project, or the rest of the five-phase plan. “No cost to taxpayers” has cost taxpayers more than five million dollars and counting.
The old library building at 46 Mt. Pleasant Avenue was sold to developer Joe Alpert for $1 million. Then, according to Councilwoman Rudin, the council gave $500,000 of that back to help him obtain his certificate of occupancy. Seniors who moved into the building next door were told that community space would be theirs. At the June 9th council meeting, residents came and said they had never gotten that space. Then the administration put forward a resolution to hire an architectural firm for $56,930 to convert that same space into new municipal offices. The council voted it down, 3 to 2. Councilwoman Williams asked directly: “What was all of that, a bait and switch?” Councilwoman Rudin confirmed it: “This was never intended to be office space by the government. Let’s keep our promise to the people.”
And the dog park tells a similar story. It’s a fenced gravel lot. No grass, no shade, two young saplings. Stone that gets hot enough in summer to burn paws. At one point, conditions got so unsanitary it had to be closed entirely.
More redevelopment deals are coming — not fewer. The question is whether we negotiate them well. This library deal is what happens when a town accepts a public benefit because it sounds good in a press release, without pricing out what it will actually cost to operate and maintain over time.
That’s the standard I want for every future deal this council makes: real public benefits, priced honestly, with the long-term cost on the table before anyone signs anything. That starts with being honest about what these deals really cost — before we make the next one.
Greetings West Orange. On June 11th, I posted about the Transit-Oriented Development session at the NJ Planning & Redevelopment Conference. NJ Transit’s pitch was straightforward: they score every municipality on land use, equity, investment, and community engagement to figure out where transit-friendly development is most possible and most needed, and they actively partner with towns that have done the planning work in advance. The towns that haven’t done the work wait longer and get worse deals. I said then this might deserve its own post. I’ve spent weeks since digging through West Orange’s own records. Here’s what I found.
In April 2008, West Orange adopted the Harvard Press Redevelopment Plan, covering five parcels on Mitchell Street and Central Avenue near the Highland Avenue corridor. The plan called for 89 new residential units — specifically for-sale condominiums, not rentals. The ordinance language is direct: “The residential units shall be condominium type units that are individually sold… not rented.”
That’s West Orange, on the record, deciding this land should build ownership housing for our residents. Here’s what actually happened. Only one of the five parcels — 22–24 Central Avenue — was ever built out, and it wasn’t condos. It was a 100-unit rental building. The one condition West Orange actually wrote into law for this corridor does not appear to have been honored on the one parcel that did get built. The other four parcels are, as I confirmed standing on the ground myself, still exactly what they were in 2008: vacant, fenced, and doing nothing for anyone.
The Selecto-Flash and Biddleman site is the clearest test of whether that ambition means anything. Timeline, straight from the public record:
So here’s the question I’m genuinely asking: was this March 2025 extension a routine procedural step, or did the town have real leverage here and just decline to use it?
Orange, just across the line, has proven this corridor can work. Harvard Printing broke ground in the mid-2010s and delivered 128 units. Orange is currently renovating the Highland Avenue station itself — $4.3 million — with a planned application for a formal “Transit Friendly” designation. West Orange’s answer, on our own side of the same corridor, is a fraction of what we asked for in writing back in 2008.
Done right, real commercial space here means real ratables: tax revenue generated by businesses and foot traffic instead of tax burden sitting entirely on residents. It’s one of the only concrete tools this town has to relieve pressure on homeowners without cutting services, and it’s the seed of the walkable downtown residents have wanted for decades.
For seventeen years we’ve treated this land as a project to finish. I think we should start treating it as an opportunity to get right. Once it’s built, it’s built. We won’t get another chance.
Here’s what I’m committing to plainly: if I’m lucky enough to be elected, deals like this one won’t get a rubber stamp from me. No more no-bid contracts handed out because it’s easier than running a real process. No more PILOTs negotiated without asking what they need to deliver in return. Developers who have to compete for the opportunity are more likely to put real public benefits on the table — because they have to earn the win instead of assuming they’ll get it.
More soon, including what I’m finding on the specific tax terms attached to this project, and a broader vision for reimagining this deal — one that adapts to how much the market and the need for walkable commercial corridors have changed since 2017.
In May of this year, the West Orange Planning Board rejected, in a 4–4 tie, the latest application to build 496 apartments on the forested West Essex Highlands. It isn’t over. The 2020 legal settlement obligating West Orange to allow development here is still in effect, and the developer has already filed an appeal seeking to overturn the rejection.
West Essex Highlands is the loudest example of a deeper problem. West Orange is trying to navigate some of the fastest-changing pressures a town faces: affordable housing, climate resilience, and where density belongs. The document meant to guide those decisions is a 2019 reexamination of a plan rooted in 2004.
A reexamination is a light refresh, revisiting an existing plan rather than rebuilding it from current data. Montclair, South Orange, and Maplewood have all done more recent, substantial planning work — and the gap isn’t just age. It’s substance.
Every recent plan I reviewed alongside West Orange’s shares five traits. They set real numbers and deadlines, not vague language like “encourage” or “explore.” They consider who’s most affected by housing decisions: renters, seniors, lower-income residents, not just the town’s physical layout. They’re backed by real data. They name who’s responsible for each recommendation, and by when. And they treat affordable housing as something the town must deliver, not just hope for.
The differences are striking. Montclair requires a 20% affordable housing set-aside on qualifying developments of five or more units. Maplewood names its unmet need specifically: 362 units, a concrete benchmark residents can measure progress against. Culver City, California concentrates new housing around transit infrastructure. Evanston, Illinois uses a Housing and Transportation Affordability Index, recognizing that true affordability depends on both housing costs and the cost of getting to work, school, and daily necessities.
West Orange’s plan does none of this. No measurable goals. No equity lens. No township-wide affordable housing strategy. No displacement-prevention plan. No data grounding its recommendations in who’s actually affected. No accountability mechanism tying anything to a timeline or a responsible party.
The consequences of governing without a real plan aren’t hypothetical. In 2006, after residents fought off an earlier development of West Essex Highlands, the Township Council voted to appraise the forest for purchase with state Green Acres funds. The appraisal was withheld from the public. Resident Professor Paul Tractenberg had to sue the township just to see it, and the fight reached the Appellate Division before West Orange was ordered to release it in 2010. The acquisition never happened. The land stayed privately owned, and in 2020 its owner filed a builder’s remedy lawsuit that forced the town into a settlement obligating the site to the very development the Planning Board just rejected.
Then came 2025. Every New Jersey municipality faced a June 30, 2025 deadline to adopt a Fourth Round affordable housing plan or lose legal immunity from builder’s remedy lawsuits. West Orange missed it. Roughly 94% of New Jersey municipalities didn’t. The consequences arrived immediately: Daughters of Israel and the developer of the former Mayfair Farms site both filed builder’s remedy lawsuits within weeks. By September, the Planning Board chair confirmed six such lawsuits, warning residents: “We are at risk now, and we will be at risk until this is adopted.”
Instead of a unified response, West Orange got a public shouting match. McCartney blamed the council for “inaction.” The council disputes that, saying the administration sat on the matter for over a year after approving a firm in 2024, then presented a rushed contract just ninety days before the deadline. Both sides have documented versions of those events. But a single, directly accountable executive is the whole argument for a strong-mayor system — and part of that job is basic contingency planning. A ninety-day runway before a known deadline left no room for exactly the pushback that occurred.
A new master plan is the only real defense a town has against exactly what West Orange is living through right now. Done right, it would:
West Essex Highlands wasn’t inevitable. It became harder to avoid every year the town went without replacing an outdated plan. West Orange has had two decades and multiple administrations to build that plan. It hasn’t. The forest is still standing today because residents fought for it in court and in front of the Planning Board.
This has to change. It begins with doing the work we’ve postponed for a generation: writing a modern master plan that reflects the West Orange we’re becoming, not the one we’ve already left behind.
On Tuesday night, the West Orange Township Council unanimously settled the Daughters of Israel builder’s remedy lawsuit.* Given the circumstances, I recognize this was probably the best outcome we could reasonably hope for. But that doesn’t make it any less frustrating.
We sat through nearly two hours of emotional testimony about the overwhelmingly positive impact Daughters of Israel has had on our community. I don’t question that legacy. But we need to distinguish the nonprofit’s mission from this next phase of development: a 311-unit continuing care retirement community, including 163 market rate independent living apartments, with just seven assisted-living units qualifying as affordable housing.
And because of a systemic breakdown in our municipal government, we’ve lost much of our ability to shape what gets built. Daughters of Israel’s original proposal was rejected by the Zoning Board. But a zoning denial doesn’t necessarily mean “no.” Often, it means “not like this.” Address the concerns, make some changes, and come back. I know the process can be exhausting, expensive, and frustrating, but it exists for a reason. It’s how we consider the impact of development on our neighborhoods, infrastructure, and the future of West Orange.
After West Orange missed its affordable housing deadline, Daughters of Israel pursued a builder’s remedy lawsuit rather than returning to the Zoning Board with a revised proposal. That gave it considerably more leverage in negotiating with the township. Our government’s failure to meet its obligations weakened the process designed to protect the community and left residents with far less say in the outcome.
Responsibility for what happened doesn’t rest with any one person or branch of government. Under West Orange’s strong-mayor form of government, the administration is responsible for managing the township’s day-to-day operations, including ensuring that the township meets its affordable housing obligations. Our mayor served on both the Township Council and Planning Board during Round Three and should have been better prepared for Round Four. And our former township attorney should have made certain that everyone understood the consequences of missing the June 30, 2025 deadline.
That doesn’t absolve the Council of responsibility. On April 22, 2025, members were warned that West Orange was already behind schedule and vulnerable to builder’s remedy lawsuits. Yet they rejected a proposed $50,500 planning contract, with some arguing for a full-time planner and others questioning the terms.
Those concerns weren’t unreasonable, and the vote didn’t have to be the end of the road. Another firm had responded to the township’s request for qualifications, and the administration could at least have explored bringing an alternative proposal before Council at a special meeting. But neither branch of our government found a workable path in time, and the plan wasn’t filed by June 30.
There were warnings. There were opportunities to act. And now residents are left to pick up the pieces.
But even if West Orange had met every deadline, a larger question would remain. I’m glad the development will remain senior housing, particularly because of my concerns about the impact of residential growth on our schools. But as I watch “luxury” rentals popping up across West Orange, I struggle with a housing model that increasingly treats a basic human need as an opportunity for profit. When we’re invoking affordable housing obligations to justify development that is largely market-rate, I think we’re entitled to ask: Whom does this system really serve?
I’ve revisited this issue many times during my campaign, always with frustration. We can’t undo what’s happened, but we can find the best path forward from years of poor decisions and indecision. And the difficult truth is that four more builder’s remedy lawsuits remain. I suspect each will bring some measure of quiet frustration, perhaps even despair, as we confront just how much control we’ve surrendered.
But despair isn’t a luxury for those of us signing up, eyes wide open, to forge a better path for West Orange. We have to steel our spines, do our homework, ask difficult questions, and make the best decisions we can. And we have to make it easier for residents to do the same.
There are no quick fixes. But we can insist on better planning, greater transparency, and a government that acts before a crisis forces its hand. The work ahead won’t be easy, but it is worthwhile and necessary.
*The proposed zoning ordinance (Exhibit B to the settlement) was not included in the public packet. When I requested it, I was told it remained confidential. The ordinance is expected to be introduced on October 27, with a public hearing before adoption, giving residents an opportunity to review and comment on the proposed zoning changes.
Throughout this campaign, we’ve been asked to share our vision for West Orange. I’ve spent a lot of time talking about the smaller things we can do, practical changes that are realistic, affordable and, in many cases, pretty easy to implement. But I think it’s worth talking about the bigger dreams, too.
Have you ever been to downtown Maplewood in the warmer months? The streets fill up with fairs, concerts, art walks and community events. Restaurants spill outside and people walk from place to place. It’s a destination. I would love to see us create that kind of energy along Valley Road, and I think we can. Unlike other commercial districts, including our Main Street, Valley Road is controlled by West Orange, not the county, so we have the opportunity to think about what we want that whole corridor to become and start taking small steps toward it.
One of those steps could start with the Highland Avenue train station. Right now, West Orange’s jitney takes commuters to Orange, South Orange and Brick Church. What if we piloted a stop at Highland Avenue, told residents exactly what we’re trying to do and why, and encouraged commuters (especially people heading to Lower Manhattan, where that connection makes sense) to give it a try? Then we measure what happens.
Back in June, I shared what I learned during a session at the NJ Planning & Redevelopment Conference. In 2017, NJ Transit made it clear that more Midtown Direct service at Highland Avenue would depend on increased ridership. So let’s give them the ridership. NJ Transit also told us they actively partner with towns that come to them with a plan already in place. If we can show there’s real demand and a real plan, we have a much stronger case to bring to them: West Orange is ready to build around transit, so help us increase service and let’s work together on a true transit corridor.
This conversation isn’t new. Back in 2008, it was renderings and a vision for a “Valley Arts District” that convinced my family to buy our home on Tompkins. When the economy collapsed, so did the dreams for this corridor, though it thankfully brought us Luna Stage and the development next to it.
I still believe in that vision, and here’s what it could look like today. Picture mixed-use development along Valley Road, with more residents living within walking distance of shops, restaurants and the train. Envision Valley Road on a weekend afternoon, closed to cars, with music playing, tables outside the restaurants, an art walk one weekend and a Caribbean festival the next. Kids running around. Neighbors walking over instead of getting in the car to go somewhere else.
We may not have to do it alone, either. Orange has a stake in a thriving Valley Road too. They already built their half of the Harvard Press redevelopment near the station. And since Highland Avenue sits in Orange, working together could open doors to state programs, like Transit Village grants, that reward towns for planning around their train stations, along with opportunities for shared services that make this work for both towns.
None of this happens overnight. But it could start with one stop. More riders help us make the case for more service, more service supports a transit corridor, and a transit corridor could help us reimagine a whole section of our town, bring in new revenue and help us address affordable housing.
The Little Engine That Could. I think we can.
I just got back from a trip with my family that took me from the excess of Vegas to the quiet, humbling scale of Zion National Park, culminating in a hike through The Narrows with my sister — a two-time cancer survivor — by my side. The metaphor of that moment wasn’t lost on me.
I don’t hike. It’s genuinely not a thing I do. But something about the challenge — legs burning, no shortcuts, just putting one foot in front of the other next to someone who has faced the worst — reminded me of just how much I am capable of.
While I was traveling, the council held its August 18th meeting and what came out of it is something every West Orange resident needs to hear. A sitting council member confirmed on the record what was admitted in prior meetings: the roughly $9–10 million a year we collect through something called a sewer fee isn’t dedicated to our sewers. It goes into the general fund and is, in his own words, “gone.” There is no dedicated portion of that revenue reserved for sewer infrastructure. And that same night, the council approved another $3.2 million in new sewer bond debt to pay for sewer improvements.
Think about that for a moment. Residents pay millions every year under the name “sewer fee.” That money becomes general revenue. Then, when our sewer system needs capital improvements, we borrow the money and residents ultimately pay that debt too. Residents are paying twice: once through a sewer fee that disappears into the general fund, and again through the debt we’re taking on to make the sewer improvements that fee isn’t funding.
And we’re having this conversation immediately after a major storm flooded streets and homes across West Orange. Our infrastructure needs enormous investment. Residents deserve to know why we’re collecting millions every year under the name “sewer fee” while borrowing millions more to pay for sewer infrastructure.
To be clear: we can’t simply rescind this fee. At nearly 10% of the budget, it has become an essential part of how this township funds itself. That’s not the answer. The answer is a real, multi-year plan to reduce the township’s reliance on sewer fees as general revenue and begin directing more of what residents pay toward the infrastructure the fee is supposed to support.
At the August 4th meeting, the council voted to sell 18 Central Avenue. The final price after all deductions: $567,568, on parcels assessed at $654,500. No appraisal. No confirmation the remediation bond required back in March was ever posted. To be fair to the council: this was a vote to honor a binding contract signed in 2021, one the township’s own attorney confirmed obligated them to close.
I’ve talked before about what this corridor could be: a real transit-oriented commercial district anchoring the Valley. I sat down with the mayor and a former administration member to make that case directly. Both told me the deal was done.
But that’s exactly the point. It’s not the developer’s job to protect West Orange’s interests. It’s the administration’s. Edison Lofts, another PILOT-financed redevelopment born of the same logic, just resold for $131 million. That’s the market telling us, in plain numbers, how much private value can ultimately be created through redevelopment in West Orange. Residents deserve a government that understands that value before the deal is signed.
This is the work: unglamorous, diligent, arduous at times — trudging upstream against a current that doesn’t let up, showing up and going as far as you can go, because the only way through is forward. It’s good to be back.
Disciplined. Measured. Fair. That is what I aim for every time I write about someone in government, whether it is a sitting council member, a candidate, the administration, or a vote itself. And as I comb through the complicated, often frustrating history of how we got here — and more importantly, how we find our way out — I find myself repeating that mantra.
I also try to write from the perspective of what I wanted to hear as a constituent. So much of what we are dealing with today is the fallout from decisions made years, sometimes decades ago. What I wanted was someone to explain why, how, and what could actually be done next. In plain English, not legalese or deliberately opaque political speak.
I have opinions. Plenty of them. But I try not to let those opinions steer how I present the facts, and I want to explain why — because I think it matters more than it sounds like it should.
Before real estate, before my tenure as a Senior Managing Editor at Geotext Translations and later as Assistant Communications Director at Lionbridge Technologies, I spent years in the performing arts, including performing on Broadway and on television. A large part of the training that led to my success was about understanding motivation and behavior.
Something most people may not think about when they watch a play or a film is that when an actor plays an antagonist, they are not playing “evil.” They are building a completely logical worldview, based on that character’s lived experience, where the choices make sense to that character. Fear, ambition, loyalty, grievance, self-preservation. Those are the engines. A believable villain does not know they are wrong — they are certain they are right.
I bring that same approach when thinking about the people who make decisions for this town. It would be easy to telegraph motive, to let my own read on someone color every sentence. Believe me, it is tempting. But it is not accurate, and it is not fair.
Instead I try to ask the same questions I would ask about a character. What does this person actually want? What pressures are they under? What version of events makes their decision make sense from inside their own head? Understanding someone’s logic is not the same as excusing it — but it is necessary so that the facts, the vote, the money, and the outcome can speak for themselves.
One of the most consistent things I have heard from residents is that this town wants to see more collaboration, not just within each branch of our government, but across all of our bodies as a whole. I want to make it clear that the message has been well received, and I will make every attempt to remain disciplined, measured, and most importantly, fair.
Sewer bills are rolling in now, and many neighbors are reeling from the cost and struggling to understand the full scope of this fee. Tuesday night’s meeting produced some genuinely useful answers to questions residents have been raising for some time.
The mayor sent property owners a letter explaining the CY2026 Sewer User Fee and providing a detailed breakdown of the approximately $9.6 million collected through the fee in 2025. I appreciated the transparency, but a few items on that breakdown still felt vague, so I posed them during public comment Tuesday night.
The first question involved the approximately $1.46 million listed for “DPW, Engineering, Tax” salaries. The CFO walked through how he calculated it: our dedicated four-person sewer crew is counted in full, along with 15% of remaining DPW salaries, 25% of Engineering for inspections and oversight, and 35% of Tax Department salaries for administering roughly 14,000 bills through three major mailings each year.
The second question involved the $567,653 line labeled “Reserve — Revenue in Support of Other Operations.” After subtracting everything the CFO felt he could defensibly attribute to sewer-related expenses, approximately $567,000 remained. Because West Orange does not currently have a separate sewer utility, that money stays in the general fund and supports other township operations: police, fire, health, finance, and the rest of municipal government.
That gets to the concern residents have raised repeatedly: our sewer fee is currently not a dedicated sewer fund. And it raises an obvious question — if we collect more through the fee than we can reasonably attribute to sewer costs in a given year, shouldn’t some of that money be building a reserve for the next major repair instead?
The CFO described essentially that possibility. Under a true sewer utility, that remaining revenue could be reserved for future sewer projects — putting aside roughly $550,000 annually, which could reduce the amount of debt the township needs to issue later. He said this conversation may ultimately be looked back on as the “genesis” of a West Orange sewer utility.
The township has already built a sewer utility structure into its new Edmunds financial system, and is preparing to test New Jersey American Water usage data against West Orange accounts to model usage-based billing — a necessary step toward finally moving away from the bedroom-based formula that has frustrated residents for years.
There is still work to do. A utility would require financial modeling, Council action, and approval through the state’s Local Finance Board. But this is movement. We now have an actual number to work with: roughly $550,000 a year that could eventually be set aside for future sewer repairs instead of absorbed into the general fund. Knowing that now gives the township time to plan for it, rather than discovering it later. Onward.